It’s Not Just About How We Treat Each Other

Monday evening I gave a talk at World Fellowship entitled “Eco-Terrorism: the New Communism” with Will Potter, author of Green is the New Red. I addressed some differences between what I called the “traditional left” and the radical environmental and animal rights movement.

The Marxist/socialist critique of capitalism argued that the earth’s resources should be distributed more evenly among all human beings. The problem was the way the factory was organized, not the factory itself. The Marxist view was an anthropocentric one. It questioned the right of the ruling classes to exploit other people’s labor in order to control a disproportionate share of the earth’s resources, but it assumed that humans had the right to enjoy the fruits of those resources fairly.

The radical environmental and animal rights movements have a broader definition of exploitation. They view the exploitation of the earth’s resources, be they plant, animal or mineral, as problematic. Put another way, it is not just how the factory is organized, but the factory, itself that is the problem.

Both my birth and adoptive parents were members of the Communist Party and I was raised as a Red Diaper baby. So it is hardly surprising that even though I have been interested in environmental issues since the 1970s, most of my political activism has concerned how people treat others, rather than how we interact with the plants and animals around us.

However, as we’ve learned more about the consequences of humanity’s rapidly intensifying exploitation of our planet, our impact on our environment has become impossible for me to ignore. We can’t fault Marx for not considering the sustainability of industrial development, but we must take into account what we’ve learned since the mid-19th century. Just in the last 50 years have we figured out that human beings are a part of a complex and interdependent planetary web of existence. Only more recently have we realized that it is perilous to ignore the fact that earth is not here for human benefit.

I fear many of my fellow human beings, even those with progressive sensibilities, think of our species as the pinnacle rather than a part of existence on this planet. We cannot indefinitely stand in opposition to or apart from our natural setting because we are it, and it is us. We can succeed in manipulating the environment and appropriate a non-sustainable share of the globe’s resources for a time, but the planet, not any single species, holds the trump card.

This is why I feel that we can no longer let environmental concerns take a back seat to other struggles. I am not advocating the abandonment of battles for economic and social justice; we must never give up the fight to eliminate injustice and alleviate suffering. In fact, the point I hope I made in my talk at World Fellowship is that we must work to bridge the gap between the traditional left and the radical environmental and animal rights movements. More traditional left efforts must take place in the context of work to reverse the damage that threatens our planet’s ability to maintain the vast network it sustains. If we don’t do this, we will be unable to prevent devastating the quality of most life, including our own.

To receive a notification whenever there is a new post to Out on a Limb Together, subscribe now.


The whole culture is the terrain of the change we seek, and our attitude toward nature is included.

Of course, the Rosenberg Fund has been *doing* this for many years: for 12 years -- starting just after I met you,. at the incredibly moving 40th-year commemorative art show in Boston -- I moved to Mendocino County, California, where I then lived for 12 years. There, I wound up facilitating an explosively controversial public process to discuss regulation of the "timber" industry, which was then clear-cutting the third-growth redwoods. (All the corporations have since finished extracting their profits and pulled out -- of the country! And yet, Mendocino County is doing OK, despite the corporate honchos' threats to "our way of life.")

The Earth First! car-bombing took place at the beginning of the summer when the months-long public-hearing process started: to your credit, the daughter of Judi Bari z"l (herself a gifted violinist, as well as a committed environmental activist) was supported by the Rosenberg Fund to attend a summer music camp, far from the valley where her mother was being excoriated for her activism -- and blamed by the FBI for "bombing herself."

I was so proud that out of the horror of your own family's story, you had found a center for empathy and healing for the children of such important activists -- prickly, yes, often irritating, but dead-on in her analysis. Let us not compromise in defending the earth from US: keep up the good work!

we've been fracked by big oil and big natural gas causing earthquakes-flamable water from kitchen faucets-gasoline underground line explosion in wellingtom ohio- (thankfully in sub-freezing weather) huge explosion next to a old folks facility-(thankfully the strong winds blew the flames-fumes away from the facility) [emman-u el?]
and poisoned by engineered and chemical additives in food-corn-animal products-by big "con" agriculture -monsanto-+ other corporations-
public utilities have become private investments in the stock market- our health is in the hands of insurance-"food" corporations-- What to do?? What to Do// (the sky is falling,said Henny Penny) My Father said--
"Back to the farm and get a horse, (I may add cow)--But the gentle work horses ("Grade Horse") are now being cruelly slaughtered and sold as meat accross the pond. These creatures are so like us in loyalty-feelings-gentleness, We Could be Next on "The Plate"!-a grey eagle

Not only human beings but animals, plants and other species all are important to environment. If any of the species of animal or plant disappear from the earth, we don't know what effect it will have on Environment. Injustice to environment should be as equavalent to Injustice to any human being.

  • There's many betting sites for aussie online players but if you prefer the very best pokies online you should visit this particular gambling site that is loaded with evaluations and slot machines online games downloads.

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.